
In the first part of our Canberra Raiders season preview, we take an in depth look at the club's recruitment and retention for 2024.
The recruits
2023. It was the season that did not add up. The Raiders finished the regular season in the bottom five teams in attack and defence - and with a negative points differential of 137 points. Yet they finished in the top eight - and just missed progressing to the second week of the finals after a classic quarter final loss. They made the finals because they were gritty. They were "brawlers" at times - as Ricky Stuart described the style of team he was hoping to build - and they bled green. But it also was not enough.
Times have changed since the Raiders made the Grand Final in 2019. Only seven players who ran onto the field that night are with the Green Machine in 2024. The likes of Croker, Wighton, Hodgson, Soliola, Leilua and Nicoll-Klokstad are all gone. The style of the game has also moved on. Grindball was put out of business by Vlandysball. And while the extremes of the latter have subsided with even more rule changes, the game of rugby league has certainly changed.
So there are two major challenges facing the brains trust at Braddon. Potentially, they're interrelated.
The first is how to manage the significant generational change that is underway. After playing his 300th NRL match last year, Jarrod Croker has retired. After 13 years with the club, and almost 250 NRL games, Jack Wighton has defected to the Rabbitohs. It looks like Father Time will even catch up with Elliott Whitehead and Jordan Rapana. This season is shaping as the last in the game for the two 34 year olds.
Heading into the 2023 season, the Raiders had one of the older squads in the NRL, at an average age of over 26. This year, the top 30 squad has an average age of barely more than 24.
It is the time for generation next, according to coach Ricky Stuart.
"Over the next 12 months we're going to be transitioning into a new era," Stuart recently told The Canberra Times.
"We'll be losing 1000 games of NRL experience with Jarrod and Jack leaving this year, Elliott and Jordan being their last season in '24. So there is an enormous amount of experience that we'll be losing and it's going to be a very challenging period for us as a club, but I'm certainly looking at it as a positive and a massive opportunity... to afford our younger players a fantastic opportunity to become regular NRL players.
"There's going to be times in this transition... where there will be inconsistencies whilst we're developing this young group. I'm excited by what lies ahead for us. I'm really looking forward to these younger guys really grasping their opportunity and becoming the next generation."
The other major challenge facing the club is how to find a style of football that will better suit the times. In one sense, the process of generational change will help. The average age of NRL players has been declining. In 2017 and 2018, players were over 28 years of age, on average. The average age was around 25 in the past three years. Rugby league has increasingly become a young man's game.
Of course, a balance has to be maintained. Clubs like the Tigers know that a squad can be too young. Some older, experienced heads are needed. However, in the era of more up tempo rugby league, a club like the Panthers has thrived with a younger squad.
The Raiders are going to gamble on youth in 2024. In some ways, they haven't had much choice. There was a surfeit of good, established talent in the positions of need on the market. There were no ready made replacements available for Jack Wighton. They have also found it tough to attract higher profile players, failing in their long term pursuit of David Fifita. So the Raiders have largely focussed on young talent in recruitment. And in creating pathways for some exciting young players already with the club.
There might be some difficult times in the next year or two. But if the club gets things right, it could set the Green Machine up for another premiership window. A young team, playing an exciting brand of football. New times, that might even hark back to some golden times of the past.
So what of the new recruits?
Morgan Smithies
Morgan Smithies is Canberra's highest profile recruit of 2024. The Raiders' interest in the Wigan Warriors forward was kept very quiet - until after the Super League season had finished. The news of the his three year deal broke in mid October - and it only took a couple of weeks to agree with Wigan on a transfer fee and for the contract to be made official.
Born in Halifax, the 23 year old Englishman has played 114 first class games with the Wigan Warriors over five seasons. He's tasted victory in the 2022 Challenge Cup final and the 2023 Super League Grand Final. He's also played one game for England so far - against France last year. That's quite a bit of experience for such a young forward.
Smithies is primarily a lock forward. He's made 69 appearances for Wigan in that role. But he can also play in the second row (13 games) and even in the front row (two games). He stands at 185cms and weighs in at 106kgs, so he has physical presence, but is still mobile.
He's a noted defender. He set a record for most tackles in a Super League match (72) in 2019, at the age of 18. In last year's Super League Grand Final, he made 55 tackles, while posting 100 per cent tackle efficiency. In 2023, he ranked fourth in the Super League competition for most tackles (35 per game), while missing only 1.6 tackles per match.
His attacking numbers last year were not so strong. He averaged around 75 running metres per game, six metres per run and produced only three offloads, one line break and 21 tackle breaks in total. Smithies says he's been working on the attacking side of his game.
"I played loose forward at Wigan last year and just working on my ball-handling skills," he said recently.
"I feel like they progressed, but I'm not too bothered where I play. I'll play wherever for Sticky. As long as I'm playing I'm not too bothered where I play. Whether it's 13 or second row I'm not too bothered. I'll just be happy to play for Canberra."
"I'm a hard worker, but over the past few years I've tried to add a bit more on to my game - a bit of skill in the attack - but defensively I'll be pretty sweet."
Matt Timoko has reported that Smithies has shown some "great ball skills" in pre-season training. Assistant coach Mick Crawley recently backed that up. Maybe Smithies' 2023 numbers reflect what he was instructed to do at Wigan. Maybe we'll see more adventure from him in attack in 2024. We all shall soon see.
Zac Hosking
Zac Hosking was signed by the Raiders from the Panthers in early January this year. Released from the final year of his contract at Penrith, he's been given a three year deal. His father, David, played for the Rabbitohs and Sea Eagles in the late 1980s and early 1990s. A prop known as "The Mule". His nickname tells you a lot about he approached the game and his physique. He was tough and rugged. Zac is lankier, standing at 188cms and weighing in at 97kgs. More suited to the second row. But he's not flashy either. Defence is more his forte.
Born at Manly, Hosking will be 27 years of age by the time the 2024 season starts. He played his junior football in Newcastle with Centrals, before making his NSW Cup debut for the Knights in 2018. He twice won Newcastle's NSW Cup Player of the Year award, but he couldn't get a first grade start. After four seasons - interrupted by the pandemic - and 43 Cup games, the part time carpenter headed to Brisbane in 2022. He'd thought his NRL dream was pretty much over, but he took up a train and trial opportunity with the Broncos. And Hosking was rewarded with his NRL debut in the Broncos' Round 22 clash with the Dragons at Lang Park.
Hosking played four NRL matches with Brisbane in 2022, as well as 15 Queensland Cup games with the Wynnum Manly Seagulls. He took an offer to join the Panthers for the 2023 season, on a two year deal. He made 21 appearances for Penrith last year, including the Qualifying Final. He was given an opportunity with Liam Martin affected by injury and he grabbed it. However, he was snubbed by coach Ivan Cleary in the two biggest games of the year. Luke Garner was preferred for the Preliminary Final and Grand Final.
Prior to Christmas, he jumped at the chance of a meeting with Ricky Stuart during Canberra's training camp in Kiama. And by January, he was training in green.
Hosking started in the second row in 15 games last year, while playing two at centre and four off the bench. He scored three tries and produced six total try involvements. He also averaged nine runs for 73 metres, while posting four line breaks, 31 tackle breaks and 13 offloads. All those numbers were outside the top 20 second rowers in the competition.
Hosking averaged 26 tackles per game - and his tackle efficiency was pretty good at 91 per cent. It is not a huge defensive workload, but the tackle efficiency was in the top 20 second rowers. He was well down the list for try causes (five) and line break causes (nine). His error count was fairly low and his penalty count was very low.
Hosking's a solid player and adds some depth in a position where it is sorely needed. There is doubt about whether Corey Harawira-Naera will be cleared to return to the field after his on-field seizure last year. And the game time of captain Elliott Whitehead will likely need to be managed. It is likely we'll see a fair bit of Hosking on the bench in first grade, at the least.
Kaeo Weekes
Kaeo Weekes, 21, was signed by the Raiders last October on a two year deal. He is an Asquith Magpies junior, a feeder club for the North Sydney Bears. A junior athletics sprint champion with Newington College, he scored 11 tries in his first season of Harold Matthews with Manly. He made his NSW Cup in 2021 and his NRL debut followed soon after - the Round 19 clash with the Dragons in 2022.
Weekes was almost exclusively a fullback for Manly in NSW Cup. He played four of his 12 NRL games at the back too. But he can also play in the halves. Either way, his path to first grade has been blocked at the Sea Eagles, by the likes of Tom Trbojevic and Josh Schuster. When Trbojevic was out in the back end of 2023, Reuben Garrick was mostly preferred at fullback as well. By then, the Sea Eagles were looking in other directions.
Weekes is in a battle with 19 year old half, Ethan Strange, for the Raiders' No. 6 jersey. And he is being widely tipped as the winner of that battle, including by one Sydney journalist who has good connections at Raiders HQ. That was initially a a bit of a surprise for me, as Weekes has played only two senior games at five eighth and one at halfback at Manly. His advantage is his speed. He's clocked in during the pre-season as the second fastest player at the club over 20 metres, behind Xavier Savage. The trials will tell us more. Whoever wins the five eighth role has some big shoes to fill.
Simi Sasagi
Simi Sasagi, 22, was born in Auckland and played his junior football with the Ellerslie Eagles. He joined the Newcastle Knights at SG Ball level in 2018 - and was given a development contract in 2019. Promoted to the Newcastle top 30 squad in 2021, he made his NRL debut at centre, in the Round 11 clash with the Cowboys. He played 17 first grade matches with the Knights, two at centre, the rest off the bench. But Sasagi didn't get a look in at first grade last year. Newcastle agreed to release him last August, so he could sign a two year deal with the Raiders.
Sasagi has utility value. He's mostly played at centre or lock, but he's also played eight of his 34 NSW Cup games at five eighth and two at halfback.
"For this year, I want to settle myself in either the back row, anywhere in the middle I guess," he said after arriving in Canberra.
"I've had conversations with Ricky Stuart... being able to play multiple positions, I think, just where ever I can in the team. But I probably want to cement that middle or back row position."
RECRUITMENT AND RETENTION RATING: C+ The list of recruits is a bit thin, while the Raiders have lost a fair bit of depth in key positions.
The departure of Jack Wighton, Matt Frawley and Brad Schneider leaves Jamal Fogarty as the only senior half standing. If Fogarty is lost to injury or suspension, the Raiders could be in some trouble. The club will not only be depending on young players to step up in the halves, but also at fullback.
Edge forward is a problem area, given strong doubts over the availability of Corey Harawira-Naera and the impending retirement of Elliott Whitehead. The recruitment of Zac Hosking helps there - but he's probably not the "point of difference" recruit the club was after when they were attempting to sign David Fifita or Keaon Koloamatangi. Depth at centre is now also an issue, with the loss of Croker, Smith-Shields and Morkos.
All that sounds a bit grim. But the list of re-signings is fairly strong. Morgan Smithies could turn out to be a very strong pick up. In addition, the club has already recruited some of the best young players country in the past year or two. Think Chevy Stewart and Ethan Strange. And there is a strong junior development base. There are potential long term fullbacks, halves and hookers already at the club. Some are ready, or close to ready, some are in the pipeline.
The Raiders are also ready to recruit Eels and junior Blues halfback Ethan Sanders - once Round 6 rolls around, and they are able to officially negotiate with him for 2025. Maybe the Raiders could even get him early. Add him to the list of recruits and it wouldn't be a bad haul. At the very least, Canberra will have built well for the future.
Gains: Zac Hosking (Penrith Panthers, 2026), Simi Sasagi (Newcastle Knights, 2025), Morgan Smithies (Wigan Warriors, 2026), Kaeo Weekes (Manly Sea Eagles, 2025)
Losses: Jarrod Croker (retired), Matt Frawley (Leeds Rhinos), Brad Morkos (released), Brad Schneider (Hull Kingston Rovers, Penrith Panthers), Harley Smith-Shields (Gold Coast Titans), Clay Webb (Newcastle Knights NSW Cup), Jack Wighton (South Sydney Rabbitohs)
Re-signed: Michael Asomua (2026), Jamal Fogarty (2026), Emre Guler (2025), Albert Hopoate (2025), Corey Horsburgh (2027), Sebastian Kris (2027), Danny Levi (2025), Ata Mariota (2026), Hohepa Puru (2025), Jordan Rapana (2024), Tom Starling (2025), Chevy Stewart (2027), Adrian Trevilyan (2024), Hudson Young (2027)
Off contract 2024: Nick Cotric, Peter Hola, Trey Mooney, Jordan Rapana, Pasami Saulo, James Schiller, Adrian Trevilyan, Elliott Whitehead, Zac Woolford
2024 top 30 squad: Nick Cotric, Jamal Fogarty, Emre Guler, Corey Harawira-Naera, Peter Hola, Albert Hopoate, Corey Horsburgh, Zac Hosking, Sebastian Kris, Danny Levi, Ata Mariota, Trey Mooney, Josh Papalii, Hohepa Puru, Jordan Rapana, Simi Sasagi, Pasami Saulo, Xavier Savage, James Schiller, Morgan Smithies, Tom Starling, Chevy Stewart, Ethan Strange, Joseph Tapine, Matt Timoko, Kaeo Weekes, Elliott Whitehead, Zac Woolford, Hudson Young
2024 supplementary list: Utoloa Asomua (top 30 from 2025), Jordan Martin, Noah Martin (top 30 from 2026), Vena Patuki-Case (top 30 from 2025), Adrian Trevilyan

Plus follow us on Facebook: @TheGHRaiders and Instagram: @TheGHRaiders