Three time premiership winner and CC medalist doesn’t have the class for rep football.
You are right, they should select Hynes.
Moderator: GH Moderators
Three time premiership winner and CC medalist doesn’t have the class for rep football.
Addo Carr is exactly what NSW should avoid. He's fallen off a cliff since leaving Melbourne. Carries on like a Muppet as well. He, Latrell and Jarome Luai should be kept well away.
HahahaBluesbrother wrote:Addo Carr is exactly what NSW should avoid. He's fallen off a cliff since leaving Melbourne. Carries on like a Muppet as well. He, Latrell and Jarome Luai should be kept well away.
Dylan Edwards a battlerafgtnk wrote: ↑May 4, 2024, 11:47 pm Couldn't care what he's won - he's still a toiler. He's playing in a very special team, with a very special system. He's a cog in that. He won't have the luxury of the same conditions at Origin level, nor will he be facing the quality of opposition he does at club level.
QLD will likely be lining up with Reece Walsh at fullback. Do you think Edwards matches up to that? We need pure game breakers and match winners in Origin, not battlers in good club form punching above their weight.
Will be interesting to say which way Madge goes, but I’d be happy if he picked Teddy. Ever reliable, and he’s proven highly effective at that level.Hong Kong Raider wrote: ↑May 5, 2024, 12:27 am Tedesco look very slow chasing Mam last night. I wouldn't be picking him. He plays a bit like Paul Gallen in SOO. Turbo had his worst game against us. Edwards is in better form than both. Personally I'd go with Edwards but would be happy with Turbo.
NSW have a lot of uncertainties in their side - FB, centres, 5/8, middle forwards. I expect Qld to win again. Slater is good tactically, picks the right players, and can motivate them (e.g Munster having COVID and Dearden playing). He's sharp. Very impressive.
Hang on, isn't Strange going to Captain-Coach Australia? I mean he could skip over SOO, but it seems unlikely.Seiffert82 wrote:Ethan Strange and Xav Sav are the closest things we have to an Origin level player at the moment.
So yeah, I can't see any Raiders reps this year.
Sent from my CPH2021 using Tapatalk
Why is that? Seems to work well for Penrith.yeh raiders wrote: ↑May 5, 2024, 1:24 pmWill be interesting to say which way Madge goes, but I’d be happy if he picked Teddy. Ever reliable, and he’s proven highly effective at that level.Hong Kong Raider wrote: ↑May 5, 2024, 12:27 am Tedesco look very slow chasing Mam last night. I wouldn't be picking him. He plays a bit like Paul Gallen in SOO. Turbo had his worst game against us. Edwards is in better form than both. Personally I'd go with Edwards but would be happy with Turbo.
NSW have a lot of uncertainties in their side - FB, centres, 5/8, middle forwards. I expect Qld to win again. Slater is good tactically, picks the right players, and can motivate them (e.g Munster having COVID and Dearden playing). He's sharp. Very impressive.
Bigger issue is having Yeo at first receiver. That needs to be eradicated if NSW are any chance of winning.
If it wasn't for the injury I'd like to see what Papenhuyzen could do in the origin arena. He's super fit and offers more in attack than Edwards. They talk about Edwards knocking on the door for a long time Papenhuyzen has been doing it for longer. I think a lot of folks seems to have forgotten just how elite he is.Hong Kong Raider wrote: ↑May 5, 2024, 12:27 am Tedesco look very slow chasing Mam last night. I wouldn't be picking him. He plays a bit like Paul Gallen in SOO. Turbo had his worst game against us. Edwards is in better form than both. Personally I'd go with Edwards but would be happy with Turbo.
NSW have a lot of uncertainties in their side - FB, centres, 5/8, middle forwards. I expect Qld to win again. Slater is good tactically, picks the right players, and can motivate them (e.g Munster having COVID and Dearden playing). He's sharp. Very impressive.
Sure, why not.Dr Zaius wrote:Hang on, isn't Strange going to Captain-Coach Australia? I mean he could skip over SOO, but it seems unlikely.Seiffert82 wrote:Ethan Strange and Xav Sav are the closest things we have to an Origin level player at the moment.
So yeah, I can't see any Raiders reps this year.
Sent from my CPH2021 using Tapatalk
No. Hope this helpsSeiffert82 wrote: ↑May 5, 2024, 8:30 pmSure, why not.Dr Zaius wrote:Hang on, isn't Strange going to Captain-Coach Australia? I mean he could skip over SOO, but it seems unlikely.Seiffert82 wrote:Ethan Strange and Xav Sav are the closest things we have to an Origin level player at the moment.
So yeah, I can't see any Raiders reps this year.
Sent from my CPH2021 using Tapatalk
Is that in relation to something I've said about him?
Sent from my CPH2021 using Tapatalk
It does!Finchy wrote:No. Hope this helpsSeiffert82 wrote: ↑May 5, 2024, 8:30 pmSure, why not.Dr Zaius wrote:Hang on, isn't Strange going to Captain-Coach Australia? I mean he could skip over SOO, but it seems unlikely.Seiffert82 wrote:Ethan Strange and Xav Sav are the closest things we have to an Origin level player at the moment.
So yeah, I can't see any Raiders reps this year.
Sent from my CPH2021 using Tapatalk
Is that in relation to something I've said about him?
Sent from my CPH2021 using Tapatalk
How did Edwards go trying to cut down Mam when he scored a hatrick in the GF last year?Hong Kong Raider wrote: ↑May 5, 2024, 12:27 am Tedesco look very slow chasing Mam last night. I wouldn't be picking him. He plays a bit like Paul Gallen in SOO. Turbo had his worst game against us. Edwards is in better form than both. Personally I'd go with Edwards but would be happy with Turbo.
NSW have a lot of uncertainties in their side - FB, centres, 5/8, middle forwards. I expect Qld to win again. Slater is good tactically, picks the right players, and can motivate them (e.g Munster having COVID and Dearden playing). He's sharp. Very impressive.
Yeh, nah. The first try Mam had too much space running on an angle. Edwards nearly got him and could have if he had 10 more metres. The 2nd and 3rd tries didn't involve Edwards. He makes a crucial tackle on Walsh late in the game.afgtnk wrote: ↑May 5, 2024, 10:52 pmHow did Edwards go trying to cut down Mam when he scored a hatrick in the GF last year?Hong Kong Raider wrote: ↑May 5, 2024, 12:27 am Tedesco look very slow chasing Mam last night. I wouldn't be picking him. He plays a bit like Paul Gallen in SOO. Turbo had his worst game against us. Edwards is in better form than both. Personally I'd go with Edwards but would be happy with Turbo.
NSW have a lot of uncertainties in their side - FB, centres, 5/8, middle forwards. I expect Qld to win again. Slater is good tactically, picks the right players, and can motivate them (e.g Munster having COVID and Dearden playing). He's sharp. Very impressive.
If we go with picking 'in form' players like Edwards, then may as well call the series for QLD before it's played. Surely we've learnt in recent years that this approach has failed terribly.
You hate to see it.Dr Zaius wrote:It does!Finchy wrote:No. Hope this helpsSeiffert82 wrote: ↑May 5, 2024, 8:30 pmSure, why not.Dr Zaius wrote:Hang on, isn't Strange going to Captain-Coach Australia? I mean he could skip over SOO, but it seems unlikely.Seiffert82 wrote:Ethan Strange and Xav Sav are the closest things we have to an Origin level player at the moment.
So yeah, I can't see any Raiders reps this year.
Sent from my CPH2021 using Tapatalk
Is that in relation to something I've said about him?
Sent from my CPH2021 using Tapatalk
The speed of the defensive line is too fast at origin level.Bluesbrother wrote: ↑May 5, 2024, 8:00 pmWhy is that? Seems to work well for Penrith.yeh raiders wrote: ↑May 5, 2024, 1:24 pmWill be interesting to say which way Madge goes, but I’d be happy if he picked Teddy. Ever reliable, and he’s proven highly effective at that level.Hong Kong Raider wrote: ↑May 5, 2024, 12:27 am Tedesco look very slow chasing Mam last night. I wouldn't be picking him. He plays a bit like Paul Gallen in SOO. Turbo had his worst game against us. Edwards is in better form than both. Personally I'd go with Edwards but would be happy with Turbo.
NSW have a lot of uncertainties in their side - FB, centres, 5/8, middle forwards. I expect Qld to win again. Slater is good tactically, picks the right players, and can motivate them (e.g Munster having COVID and Dearden playing). He's sharp. Very impressive.
Bigger issue is having Yeo at first receiver. That needs to be eradicated if NSW are any chance of winning.
Good chat. Makes sense.yeh raiders wrote: ↑May 6, 2024, 7:43 pmThe speed of the defensive line is too fast at origin level.Bluesbrother wrote: ↑May 5, 2024, 8:00 pmWhy is that? Seems to work well for Penrith.yeh raiders wrote: ↑May 5, 2024, 1:24 pmWill be interesting to say which way Madge goes, but I’d be happy if he picked Teddy. Ever reliable, and he’s proven highly effective at that level.Hong Kong Raider wrote: ↑May 5, 2024, 12:27 am Tedesco look very slow chasing Mam last night. I wouldn't be picking him. He plays a bit like Paul Gallen in SOO. Turbo had his worst game against us. Edwards is in better form than both. Personally I'd go with Edwards but would be happy with Turbo.
NSW have a lot of uncertainties in their side - FB, centres, 5/8, middle forwards. I expect Qld to win again. Slater is good tactically, picks the right players, and can motivate them (e.g Munster having COVID and Dearden playing). He's sharp. Very impressive.
Bigger issue is having Yeo at first receiver. That needs to be eradicated if NSW are any chance of winning.
QLD know they can encroach on the 10m, because the referees like to limit penalties and “let the boys play” in origin.
They also know that hitting Yeo at first receiver is highly predictable.
They know Yeo hasn’t got a lot of aces up his sleeve and is pretty easily handled by the defenders. He isn’t a dangerous ball runner.
It just doesn’t work well for NSW. They need to rely more on Cleary and forcing him to get his hands on the ball more frequently and earlier in the play, gives him the time and space he needs. It is the best option.
Saves pesky things like picking players in form.The Nickman wrote:So are they playing the Women’s Origin before a ball has even been kicked in the NRLW?
Recovering from shoulder surgery.Hong Kong Raider wrote:Is Taufa injured? Surely she makes the team.
Majority of them are playing state league at the momentThe Nickman wrote:So are they playing the Women’s Origin before a ball has even been kicked in the NRLW?