BadnMean wrote: ↑February 3, 2024, 8:35 am
Beejay wrote: ↑February 2, 2024, 9:05 pm
Botman wrote: ↑February 2, 2024, 8:35 pm
the idea that you have to have experience at the highest level of a sport to have to know what you're talking about is just silly.
I love the NFL, it's a very technical game and one i did not grow up playing or watching so nothing about learning that game was or is natural. But the people i've learnt the most from about that game are guys like Bill Barnwell, Ben Solak, Steven Ruiz, Nora Princiatti, Chris Wessling, Mina Kimes and Robert Mays... none of which played the game at any reasonable level. They're not always right, they have bad takes too, but you listen to those people and you'll get a really sound understanding of the game what is driving/pushing the game forward in terms of innovation.
You don't need to play a sport at a high level to understand it and comment on if from a place of knowledge. Former players will always say you have to but that's how you get Andrew Johns and Brad Fitler half cut on a national telecast giving you "analysis" based on their same game multis.
It's sport, its really not rocket science.
Very Dunning-Kruger vibes.
But no hate. This is the place for it.
There are dozens of winning coaches across multiple sports (Arrigio Sacchi and Parreira from football come to mind) with brilliant careers who never played professionally.
There's a million examples of top players who were abysmal coaches.
Fans run the full spectrum from guys who played a fair bit at reasonable levels to guys who never laced one up. Either can make an insightful analysis of a player or tactic.
Not Dunning-kruger at all. TBH I very much concur with botman's original point.
Just different skill sets.
Playing sport at a very high level requires (first three are pretty interchangeable pending the sport):-
1 - To be an absolute unit of an athlete.
2 - To have the very best skill set possible for that particular sport / position.
3 - To be able to try **** off hard (ties into conditioning but still)
Those three things are way above everything else.
then you have a drop off.
Then you have
4 - understanding game plan tactics for your side.
5 - making good choices all the time
6 - understanding what the other side are doing.
7 - communicating with your team mates.
A commentator / journalist wants the following skills
1 - communicating a particular point to their particular audience so that point is received as intended
2 - understanding what both sides are trying to do.
these are more comparable to that of the coaching staff then the playing staff...