SURVIVOR POLL IV: Top ten greatest ever Raiders
Moderator: GH Moderators
Re: SURVIVOR POLL IV: Top ten greatest ever Raiders
Poll declared. It’s goodbye to Brett Mullins and Glenn Lazarus. Now we vote for the top ten in order.
Re: SURVIVOR POLL IV: Top ten greatest ever Raiders
Next vote should be tight between Chicka and Toots if this poll is anything to go by
Re: SURVIVOR POLL IV: Top ten greatest ever Raiders
Basically, Furner has been replaced by Papalii on the list. I don’t really see Papalii’s record as challenging Ferguson or Croker myself. But Chicka and Croker were 10 and 8 last time.
Re: SURVIVOR POLL IV: Top ten greatest ever Raiders
His record might not challenge Furner's either pending on how you consider premierships and a CMM. But no question Papalii is a better player than Furner. So i believe Papa replacing Furner is the right call.
I think we're right into 4 very clear tiers now and how they end up within the tiers is anyones guess but:
Tier 4: Papalii, Chicka, Croker
Tier 3: Wiki, Belcher
Tier 2: Stuart, Clyde, Daley, Walters
Tier 1: Mal
Re: SURVIVOR POLL IV: Top ten greatest ever Raiders
I think that’s pretty right. How can we agree?Botman wrote: ↑June 29, 2022, 8:42 pmHis record might not challenge Furner's either pending on how you consider premierships and a CMM. But no question Papalii is a better player than Furner. So i believe Papa replacing Furner is the right call.
I think we're right into 4 very clear tiers now and how they end up within the tiers is anyones guess but:
Tier 4: Papalii, Chicka, Croker
Tier 3: Wiki, Belcher
Tier 2: Stuart, Clyde, Daley, Walters
Tier 1: Mal
Re: SURVIVOR POLL IV: Top ten greatest ever Raiders
This is how we know it's truth... two people who have wildly different views on many aspects of football can come to this very clear agreement, despite our differing experiences and perspectives.greeneyed wrote: ↑June 29, 2022, 10:07 pmI think that’s pretty right. How can we agree?Botman wrote: ↑June 29, 2022, 8:42 pmHis record might not challenge Furner's either pending on how you consider premierships and a CMM. But no question Papalii is a better player than Furner. So i believe Papa replacing Furner is the right call.
I think we're right into 4 very clear tiers now and how they end up within the tiers is anyones guess but:
Tier 4: Papalii, Chicka, Croker
Tier 3: Wiki, Belcher
Tier 2: Stuart, Clyde, Daley, Walters
Tier 1: Mal
And look, honestly i think that tells us it's not that controversial. Ill eat my **** hat if the vote doesnt pan out exactly in those tiers.
-
- Mal Meninga
- Posts: 51209
- Joined: June 25, 2012, 9:53 am
- Favourite Player: Hodgo
- Location: Rockhampton, Central Queensland
Re: SURVIVOR POLL IV: Top ten greatest ever Raiders
Mullins doesn't even make the top 10?
This whole concept is **** stupid.
This whole concept is **** stupid.