2024 NRL Round 14: Teams and Game Day

[Thomas Roy]

That last pass was forward!


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

The referee and touch judge disagree

Poor GE

[Thomas Roy]

Gee I like Wilson, he can move

Only playing because Foxx is injured

With Kiraz his path to first grade is blocked, I'd like him instead of Cotric, imagine him and Savage on the wings

[Thomas Roy]

Pups win 22-18

[The Nickman]

Doggies win! My first perfect round in the tipping since 19 dickety two

[Thomas Roy]

King Gutho still crying to the Ref

[reptar]

Gutho complaining to the ref for minutes after full time.

[Thomas Roy]

Doggies win! My first perfect round in the tipping since 19 dickety two

Woo hoo your shout big fella

[The Nickman]

Doggies win! My first perfect round in the tipping since 19 dickety two

Woo hoo your shout big fella

I'll get a free schooner for this, so come to Rocky tomorrow between the hours of about 1pm and 4pm and you can have it!

[reptar]

King Gutho still crying to the Ref

It only ended when a match day official came towards them. Might hear more about that

[-PJ-]

What’s the Matta ?

[Thomas Roy]

Doggies win! My first perfect round in the tipping since 19 dickety two

Woo hoo your shout big fella

I'll get a free schooner for this, so come to Rocky tomorrow between the hours of about 1pm and 4pm and you can have it!

Gee thanks,a bit far for me to travel unfortunately

[gerg]

Entertaining game.

Sent from my SM-G975F using Tapatalk

[zim]

Great finish by Tracey.

[Finchy]

I hate to use Graham Annesley’s thoughts on anything to justify my arguments, but he just confirmed in his presser my views on the Kyle Flanagan try.

It wasn’t a double movement because the ball carrying arm didn’t hit the ground. Try should have been awarded. The Bunker was wrong.

Graham Annesley weekly football briefing - Round 14, 2024: https://www.nrl.com/news/2024/06/11/gra ... d-14-2024/

[reptar]

I hate to use Graham Annesley’s thoughts on anything to justify my arguments, but he just confirmed in his presser my views on the Kyle Flanagan try.

It wasn’t a double movement because the ball carrying arm didn’t hit the ground. Try should have been awarded. The Bunker was wrong.

Graham Annesley weekly football briefing - Round 14, 2024: https://www.nrl.com/news/2024/06/11/gra ... d-14-2024/

Yeah, that was my interpretation as well.

And I'm STILL waiting for a definition of "strong tactical advantage"

[Finchy]

That was a horrendous Bunker decision to say that was a double movement. Watch Annesley defend it though on Monday

I apologise Mr Annesley. Glad you didn't try to defend the undefendable. Flanagan was robbed!

'It's a continuation of one motion' - Annesley: https://www.nrl.com/news/2024/06/11/its ... -annesley/

[-TW-]

What I want to know is how did nothing come from Gutho saying to Peter Gough he gifted them the game.. for getting the decisions correct

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

[Botman]

What I want to know is how did nothing come from Gutho saying to Peter Gough he gifted them the game.. for getting the decisions correct

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

Should be heavily fined and/or suspeneded. Appalling behaviour.
As EW should have been a few weeks ago

As for the Flanno try/no try... the RL community dont universially agree on much, but one thing we do agree on, is that Annesley pressers are a lottery and what he defends and what he concedes is circumstancial
Easy to say you made an error in a 40 point drubbing. Bet his response would be different if it was a close game.

I think the call was coreect based on the referee's view the tackle was complete. But RL made a really good common sense decision and decided offloads made at the time of a held call was just going to be a situation where we hand the ball back and play on, as i said at the time, i'd support circumstances like this where the call is pretty tight in terms of held vs double movement... just give the player the ball back and let him play the ball

[Finchy]

Every time I watch a replay of that try, I can't see how anyone other than the Bunker official and Botman (one and the same perhaps?) see it as a no try. The momentum never stopped, he wasn't "held". He was still moving, the ball stayed up, he can reach out to score.

Anyways... Botto and I watch the same games every week and have nearly polar opposite views on many things so it is what it is.

I'm just glad Annesley admitted it was wrong when literally every commentator and media pundit said it was a howler. In my opinion it was, and still is.

[gerg]

Every time I watch a replay of that try, I can't see how anyone other than the Bunker official and Botman (one and the same perhaps?) see it as a no try. The momentum never stopped, he wasn't "held". He was still moving, the ball stayed up, he can reach out to score.

Anyways... Botto and I watch the same games every week and have nearly polar opposite views on many things so it is what it is.

I'm just glad Annesley admitted it was wrong when literally every commentator and media pundit said it was a howler. In my opinion it was, and still is.

Like a lot of these tries they make a decision purely on the slo-mo. Now I'm not one of those buffoon commentators who whinge about these and just say completely get rid of the bunker. The bunker needs to form an opinion and then watch it at full speed again. Currently they're trying to back the on field referee too often and trying to make a decision quickly.

Sent from my SM-G975F using Tapatalk

[The Nickman]

If someone can link me to the video I'll make a decision once and for all whether Annesley got it right or not, fellas.

[President Clinton]

I was surprised the Flanagan try was a no try. Especially when you take into account the El Masri try from the ‘04 GF.

[reptar]

There was a try scored from a double movement in 1928. The crowd were incensed, and they burned down the video bunker. Moghseen Jadwat barely escaped the inferno alive, but he went on to teach Barry Gomersall how to count to 6. This caused an uproar when the referees discovered, much like the ancient Mayans, that the number 0 existed. It took that long for everyone to forget about it all before the NSWRL could reintroduce the bunker.

[The Nickman]

I'm fairly certain the reptar character has finally jumped the shark.

[reptar]

I'm fairly certain the reptar character has finally jumped the shark.

Yup. Completely lost it!

[Finchy]

If someone can link me to the video I'll make a decision once and for all whether Annesley got it right or not, fellas.

Against my better judgement, as I fear this is a massive dubby by me, here is the link again.

VIDEO: 'It's a continuation of one motion' - Annesley: https://www.nrl.com/news/2024/06/11/its ... -annesley/

[zim]

I hope Nickman is able to review this before the round gets underway. I don't like going into the next round without these things settled.

[The Nickman]

That should've been a try.

[-TW-]

Guess that wraps it all up in a neat little package

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

[President Clinton]

There was a try scored from a double movement in 1928. The crowd were incensed, and they burned down the video bunker. Moghseen Jadwat barely escaped the inferno alive, but he went on to teach Barry Gomersall how to count to 6. This caused an uproar when the referees discovered, much like the ancient Mayans, that the number 0 existed. It took that long for everyone to forget about it all before the NSWRL could reintroduce the bunker.

Source?

[reptar]

That should've been a try.

That’s what Finchy and I said at the time. As was the fashion.

[reptar]

There was a try scored from a double movement in 1928. The crowd were incensed, and they burned down the video bunker. Moghseen Jadwat barely escaped the inferno alive, but he went on to teach Barry Gomersall how to count to 6. This caused an uproar when the referees discovered, much like the ancient Mayans, that the number 0 existed. It took that long for everyone to forget about it all before the NSWRL could reintroduce the bunker.

Source?

Illuminati confirmed

[Finchy]

That should've been a try.

That’s what Finchy and I said at the time. As was the fashion.

We also had onions on our belts, which was the style at the time

[reptar]

That should've been a try.

That’s what Finchy and I said at the time. As was the fashion.

We also had onions on our belts, which was the style at the time

My belt is made of onion skin

[Finchy]

That should've been a try.

That’s what Finchy and I said at the time. As was the fashion.

We also had onions on our belts, which was the style at the time

My belt is made of onion skin

My onion skin is made of belt