2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Moderator: GH Moderators
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Some pathetic people on here really. Down to 14 after 13 minutes with scott playing on with a broken rib. Warriors getting away with at least 5 clearly forward passes including one for a try where the ref stops in line with the play giving everyone the impression hes finally called one. And here some of you are banging on about what the players could have done better. You’re pathetic.
Dont delete this GE
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Ricky Stuart refuses questions but lauds brave Canberra Raiders
Canberra coach Ricky Stuart was blunt in his assessment of the standard of officiating in his side's 34-31 loss to the New Zealand Warriors – saying he could not comment on how he really felt for fear of being fined by the NRL.
"In all my years of coaching, I've never been involved in a greater team performance," he said. "From whatever minute it was when we only had one player on the interchange bench, I have never seen a group of individuals, given we were down to 14, play so well but yet play to such adversity and play for each other.
Read more: https://www.nrl.com/news/2021/03/27/stu ... e-raiders/
Canberra Raiders show Warriors where they need to be
The New Zealand Warriors might've got the two points, but their coach Nathan Brown points to the Green Machine's effort as where they need to be if they want to be a top-four team.
"The opposition clearly showed why they've been a top-four team. Their effort to lose three players and have a bloke with a floating broken rib probably showed what they've created down here [in Canberra].
Read more: https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/ ... /?cs=14239
Forward thinking Ricky Stuart bites tongue after Canberra Raiders loss to Warriors: https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/ ... /?cs=14239
Canberra coach Ricky Stuart was blunt in his assessment of the standard of officiating in his side's 34-31 loss to the New Zealand Warriors – saying he could not comment on how he really felt for fear of being fined by the NRL.
"In all my years of coaching, I've never been involved in a greater team performance," he said. "From whatever minute it was when we only had one player on the interchange bench, I have never seen a group of individuals, given we were down to 14, play so well but yet play to such adversity and play for each other.
Read more: https://www.nrl.com/news/2021/03/27/stu ... e-raiders/
Canberra Raiders show Warriors where they need to be
The New Zealand Warriors might've got the two points, but their coach Nathan Brown points to the Green Machine's effort as where they need to be if they want to be a top-four team.
"The opposition clearly showed why they've been a top-four team. Their effort to lose three players and have a bloke with a floating broken rib probably showed what they've created down here [in Canberra].
Read more: https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/ ... /?cs=14239
Forward thinking Ricky Stuart bites tongue after Canberra Raiders loss to Warriors: https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/ ... /?cs=14239
- Rick
- Steve Walters
- Posts: 7604
- Joined: August 11, 2008, 3:56 pm
- Favourite Player: Daley
- Location: Darwin
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Nice comments from
brown.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
brown.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
- Ruben Wiki
- Posts: 5873
- Joined: June 9, 2013, 11:25 am
- Favourite Player: Ken Nagas
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
simo wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 7:31 pm Some pathetic people on here really. Down to 14 after 13 minutes with scott playing on with a broken rib. Warriors getting away with at least 5 clearly forward passes including one for a try where the ref stops in line with the play giving everyone the impression hes finally called one. And here some of you are banging on about what the players could have done better. You’re pathetic.
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Agreed. He's always seemed a good fellaRick wrote:Nice comments from
brown.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
- gangrenous
- Laurie Daley
- Posts: 16706
- Joined: May 12, 2007, 10:42 pm
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Right up until he slaps you!
-
- Simon Woolford
- Posts: 466
- Joined: March 6, 2008, 12:14 am
- Location: Perth
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Disappointed but proud!
Honestly reading some of the comments on here, really shows those that have never played the game! For the Raiders to be even close to the Warriors was a miracle.
The new rules are there to create fatigue, so three games into a season and down to 14 (13 fit) players for over 60 minutes, showed tremendous heart!
Honestly reading some of the comments on here, really shows those that have never played the game! For the Raiders to be even close to the Warriors was a miracle.
The new rules are there to create fatigue, so three games into a season and down to 14 (13 fit) players for over 60 minutes, showed tremendous heart!
Bring League West.
2010 The GH Premiership- Premiers
2010 The GH Premiership- Premiers
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
There are some red hot takes in this thread...
Sent from my Pixel 5 using Tapatalk
Sent from my Pixel 5 using Tapatalk
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Seb apparently passed his HIA assessment but Doctor's decision was that he could not play again today. So that was that.
In years gone by he would have come back on, probably at right center and the game may have had a different outcome. Long term though, player welfare has to take priority over a single NRL match. Regardless of the game outcome, the club has made the right call imo.
-
- Peter Jackson
- Posts: 268
- Joined: June 29, 2019, 9:38 pm
- Favourite Player: Mal Meninga
- Location: Toowoomba
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
No need to call other people pathetic for voicing their opinions. This was a game we were minutes from winning. So a few smarter decisions is all that was required to ice the outcome. No record book keeps track of courage; only results. The boys did so well to get into a winning position but didn't seal it. Everyone, players included, have the right to feel frustrated and question in-game decisions.simo wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 7:31 pm Some pathetic people on here really. Down to 14 after 13 minutes with scott playing on with a broken rib. Warriors getting away with at least 5 clearly forward passes including one for a try where the ref stops in line with the play giving everyone the impression hes finally called one. And here some of you are banging on about what the players could have done better. You’re pathetic.
2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
You’re pathetic.Scared Hitless wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 8:23 pmNo need to call other people pathetic for voicing their opinions. This was a game we were minutes from winning. So a few smarter decisions is all that was required to ice the outcome. No record book keeps track of courage; only results. The boys did so well to get into a winning position but didn't seal it. Everyone, players included, have the right to feel frustrated and question in-game decisions.simo wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 7:31 pm Some pathetic people on here really. Down to 14 after 13 minutes with scott playing on with a broken rib. Warriors getting away with at least 5 clearly forward passes including one for a try where the ref stops in line with the play giving everyone the impression hes finally called one. And here some of you are banging on about what the players could have done better. You’re pathetic.
Dont delete this GE
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Was at the game mate. No idea about any of that until now. Don't you reckon my statement is still valid? Thanks for offering the explanation with sarcasm.T_R wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 5:09 pmWhich guy do you think was more disappointing ... the one with the dislocated finger or the one with a broken rib?BadnMean wrote:
And some poor psoitional selections being carried cost us (Rapana). Didn't see Scott or Croker delivering much from the back 5 either.
Sent from my SM-G975F using Tapatalk
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
"smarter decisions"?Scared Hitless wrote:No need to call other people pathetic for voicing their opinions. This was a game we were minutes from winning. So a few smarter decisions is all that was required to ice the outcome. No record book keeps track of courage; only results. The boys did so well to get into a winning position but didn't seal it. Everyone, players included, have the right to feel frustrated and question in-game decisions.simo wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 7:31 pm Some pathetic people on here really. Down to 14 after 13 minutes with scott playing on with a broken rib. Warriors getting away with at least 5 clearly forward passes including one for a try where the ref stops in line with the play giving everyone the impression hes finally called one. And here some of you are banging on about what the players could have done better. You’re pathetic.
You literally have zero concept of fatigue, do you?
Sent from my Pixel 5 using Tapatalk
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Agree with that and we are seeing a lot more of it. Which is why I think we should be moving along the lines of other sports including the state leagues in our own sports and allowing concussion subs.RedRaider wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 8:15 pmSeb apparently passed his HIA assessment but Doctor's decision was that he could not play again today. So that was that.
In years gone by he would have come back on, probably at right center and the game may have had a different outcome. Long term though, player welfare has to take priority over a single NRL match. Regardless of the game outcome, the club has made the right call imo.
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
I didn't see the press conference yet or have the benefit of commentary. I go to home games and no one around me had the slightest about centres being injured- we saw James and Kris collide.julian87 wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 5:24 pmThat deserves a Jesus Christ too.BadnMean wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 5:03 pmNot a sensational performance at all when you can't control a 21 pt lead, under known circumstances.
Honestly mate, that's a failure to control a game. It's literally in the teams/coaches hands at that point. Hodgo needed to be more at dummy half- Starling could have been the lock- dumb play which had each playing their weaker suit and not their strength. Wighton went missing (impression at the ground).
And some poor psoitional selections being carried cost us (Rapana). Didn't see Scott or Croker delivering much from the back 5 either.
I count that as 2 points we threw away not 2 points lost.
The middle third forwards that were left were Josh Papalii, Ryan Sutton and Sia Soliola. The team had Havili at second row. Both centres injured.
That’s on top of some embarrassing refereeing.
Nickman unfortunately needs to add mate to his list after that post.
Watch the press conference for some reality badnmean
I honestly do think with a 21 point lead, we could have done better to manage that game. IMO more Hodgo at #9 and Starling the better suited to grunt hooker work. Wighton taking a lead like he did first half.
The refereeing is aways a weak excuse. Should never be mentioned, it's embarrassing. Every team thinks they are hard done by- even Roosters fans, trust me.
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Oi its round 3 hey
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
There are some really outraged people who support from their living room thinking they have the right to insult the fans that go to the game for voicing their own impression of the game.
-
- John Ferguson
- Posts: 2245
- Joined: June 13, 2007, 4:52 pm
- Favourite Player: Kenny Nagas
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
I think that’s true to an extent but there’s some very harsh assessments of the team and individual players on here tonight, a lot of which are too extreme. And some of which have been made without all the pertinent information.
I always go to games too but couldn’t today. My family came home from the stadium with the same impression as you about Curtis. But when you hear he broke his rib in the sixth minute you have a different impression. Those watching it on TV could see the agony he was in and how he did stuff like make two consecutive tackles on his own in spite of it.
Rapa is copping a pasting but he was outstanding today. Potentially could’ve scored the winner with his left hand but it doesn’t take away from his overall effort.
And to say good teams don’t lose when they’re up by 21 is really simplistic unrealistic stuff.
Not saying you said all or any of that, BnM, by the way. Just responding to your observation.
Personally, I just find it hard to read scathing comments when it just wasn’t a game that deserved them.
-
- Peter Jackson
- Posts: 268
- Joined: June 29, 2019, 9:38 pm
- Favourite Player: Mal Meninga
- Location: Toowoomba
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Sound like a top bloke. Can't wait to meet in person.simo wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 8:23 pmYou’re pathetic.Scared Hitless wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 8:23 pmNo need to call other people pathetic for voicing their opinions. This was a game we were minutes from winning. So a few smarter decisions is all that was required to ice the outcome. No record book keeps track of courage; only results. The boys did so well to get into a winning position but didn't seal it. Everyone, players included, have the right to feel frustrated and question in-game decisions.simo wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 7:31 pm Some pathetic people on here really. Down to 14 after 13 minutes with scott playing on with a broken rib. Warriors getting away with at least 5 clearly forward passes including one for a try where the ref stops in line with the play giving everyone the impression hes finally called one. And here some of you are banging on about what the players could have done better. You’re pathetic.
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Haha no thanks. You seem like a complete flogScared Hitless wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 9:06 pmSound like a top bloke. Can't wait to meet in person.simo wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 8:23 pmYou’re pathetic.Scared Hitless wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 8:23 pmNo need to call other people pathetic for voicing their opinions. This was a game we were minutes from winning. So a few smarter decisions is all that was required to ice the outcome. No record book keeps track of courage; only results. The boys did so well to get into a winning position but didn't seal it. Everyone, players included, have the right to feel frustrated and question in-game decisions.simo wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 7:31 pm Some pathetic people on here really. Down to 14 after 13 minutes with scott playing on with a broken rib. Warriors getting away with at least 5 clearly forward passes including one for a try where the ref stops in line with the play giving everyone the impression hes finally called one. And here some of you are banging on about what the players could have done better. You’re pathetic.
Dont delete this GE
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Na youre right.
Im sorry for living further away than you and having a 3 month old. Guess youre a much better supporter that deserves the right to bag out players that played on through injury and under fatigue. Please, continue like its not completely idiotic
Dont delete this GE
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
I watched the game on Kayo. For the Warriors first try it initially looked like an arm grab from Scott and no real effort. But he came away from that attempt with his hand on his back so there was something wrong from the get go.Ruben Daley wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 9:06 pmI think that’s true to an extent but there’s some very harsh assessments of the team and individual players on here tonight, a lot of which are too extreme. And some of which have been made without all the pertinent information.
I always go to games too but couldn’t today. My family came home from the stadium with the same impression as you about Curtis. But when you hear he broke his rib in the sixth minute you have a different impression. Those watching it on TV could see the agony he was in and how he did stuff like make two consecutive tackles on his own in spite of it.
Rapa is copping a pasting but he was outstanding today. Potentially could’ve scored the winner with his left hand but it doesn’t take away from his overall effort.
And to say good teams don’t lose when they’re up by 21 is really simplistic unrealistic stuff.
Not saying you said all or any of that, BnM, by the way. Just responding to your observation.
Personally, I just find it hard to read scathing comments when it just wasn’t a game that deserved them.
I understand that Sticky is upset and can't say what he wants to say, but through the week I hope he works on communication between the players at a kick off which is coming down close to the side line. We were on the back foot with a line drop out when we should have had the ball settling into our set. It was no surprise after that we went behind early. Similar with Jacks kick out on the full and the Warriors scored soon after. We did not defend the set back well. These are areas of the Raiders game Sticky can influence. I hope he focusses on those things we need to be better at, during the week.
-
- Jason Croker
- Posts: 4923
- Joined: July 26, 2015, 8:24 pm
- Favourite Player: Croker, Cotric, Sezer
- Location: The Land of Lime Green
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
I disagree with the idea that no-one at the game knew anything was wrong with Scott. I was at the game and it was very, very obvious that something was very wrong with Scott. His body language was wrong, the way he was carrying his upper body was wrong. I actually texted my dad just after half time and asked if they'd said on the broadcast what Scott's injury was.
They also showed Croker having his fingers relocated on the big screen, which was probably also audible to folks at home because when they first showed Croker with his arm out at an odd angle with the trainer the ground announcer was trying to rev the crowd and the big cheer turned into this odd horrified choked noise from the crowd because I was sure - and I am equally sure I wasn't alone - that he'd done his shoulder again. The relocation of his fingers got an audible groan from the crowd.
So to me, it was obvious both centres were, to a degree, injured, though Croker seemed fine after the relocation (just tired late in the game, like everyone else).
I think it was around 30-25 minutes to go that I looked up and down our line and saw our forwards completely exhausted and realised we didn't have enough points. And we still came within a whisker of winning. I don't care if some amoeba brains in here are sick of hearing it:
I'M FRICKIN PROUD OF OUR BOYS.
They never gave up. They kept trying. They didn't roll. They fought on. They fought on against a much fresher, much less tired Warriors and an absolute cheating wankstain of a referee. And they nearly did it.
Yeah, I'm gutted tonight - probably more gutted than I should be after a round 3 game where we nearly pulled off nothing short of heroics. But I am still proud of them.
And at the end of the day, after 3 rounds we're still 2-1, and we were able to limit the damage to our F/A to just 3 lost points. If Taps' ankle is okay and James and Kris recover well from their headclashes, we should bounce back strongly. Woe betide next week's opponents!
They also showed Croker having his fingers relocated on the big screen, which was probably also audible to folks at home because when they first showed Croker with his arm out at an odd angle with the trainer the ground announcer was trying to rev the crowd and the big cheer turned into this odd horrified choked noise from the crowd because I was sure - and I am equally sure I wasn't alone - that he'd done his shoulder again. The relocation of his fingers got an audible groan from the crowd.
So to me, it was obvious both centres were, to a degree, injured, though Croker seemed fine after the relocation (just tired late in the game, like everyone else).
I think it was around 30-25 minutes to go that I looked up and down our line and saw our forwards completely exhausted and realised we didn't have enough points. And we still came within a whisker of winning. I don't care if some amoeba brains in here are sick of hearing it:
I'M FRICKIN PROUD OF OUR BOYS.
They never gave up. They kept trying. They didn't roll. They fought on. They fought on against a much fresher, much less tired Warriors and an absolute cheating wankstain of a referee. And they nearly did it.
Yeah, I'm gutted tonight - probably more gutted than I should be after a round 3 game where we nearly pulled off nothing short of heroics. But I am still proud of them.
And at the end of the day, after 3 rounds we're still 2-1, and we were able to limit the damage to our F/A to just 3 lost points. If Taps' ankle is okay and James and Kris recover well from their headclashes, we should bounce back strongly. Woe betide next week's opponents!
And to all the people who doubted me, hello to them as well. - Mark Webber, Raiders Ballboy and Unluckiest F1 Driver Ever
I'm attacking in the right way, instead of just...attacking in the general direction. - Max Aaron (also eerily apropos for the Green Machine)
I'm attacking in the right way, instead of just...attacking in the general direction. - Max Aaron (also eerily apropos for the Green Machine)
-
- Peter Jackson
- Posts: 268
- Joined: June 29, 2019, 9:38 pm
- Favourite Player: Mal Meninga
- Location: Toowoomba
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
"He's a top bloke" - Mumsimo wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 9:15 pmHaha no thanks. You seem like a complete flogScared Hitless wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 9:06 pmSound like a top bloke. Can't wait to meet in person.simo wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 8:23 pmYou’re pathetic.Scared Hitless wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 8:23 pmNo need to call other people pathetic for voicing their opinions. This was a game we were minutes from winning. So a few smarter decisions is all that was required to ice the outcome. No record book keeps track of courage; only results. The boys did so well to get into a winning position but didn't seal it. Everyone, players included, have the right to feel frustrated and question in-game decisions.simo wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 7:31 pm Some pathetic people on here really. Down to 14 after 13 minutes with scott playing on with a broken rib. Warriors getting away with at least 5 clearly forward passes including one for a try where the ref stops in line with the play giving everyone the impression hes finally called one. And here some of you are banging on about what the players could have done better. You’re pathetic.
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
I will watch the replay tomorrow. At the game today, I descended into a fog of "oh this is just schnurr schnurr." I did think our centres were doing little, though my attention was drawn to Croker getting his hand fixed.raiderskater wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 9:36 pm I disagree with the idea that no-one at the game knew anything was wrong with Scott. I was at the game and it was very, very obvious that something was very wrong with Scott. His body language was wrong, the way he was carrying his upper body was wrong. I actually texted my dad just after half time and asked if they'd said on the broadcast what Scott's injury was.
They also showed Croker having his fingers relocated on the big screen, which was probably also audible to folks at home because when they first showed Croker with his arm out at an odd angle with the trainer the ground announcer was trying to rev the crowd and the big cheer turned into this odd horrified choked noise from the crowd because I was sure - and I am equally sure I wasn't alone - that he'd done his shoulder again. The relocation of his fingers got an audible groan from the crowd.
So to me, it was obvious both centres were, to a degree, injured, though Croker seemed fine after the relocation (just tired late in the game, like everyone else).
I think it was around 30-25 minutes to go that I looked up and down our line and saw our forwards completely exhausted and realised we didn't have enough points. And we still came within a whisker of winning. I don't care if some amoeba brains in here are sick of hearing it:
I'M FRICKIN PROUD OF OUR BOYS.
They never gave up. They kept trying. They didn't roll. They fought on. They fought on against a much fresher, much less tired Warriors and an absolute cheating wankstain of a referee. And they nearly did it.
Yeah, I'm gutted tonight - probably more gutted than I should be after a round 3 game where we nearly pulled off nothing short of heroics. But I am still proud of them.
And at the end of the day, after 3 rounds we're still 2-1, and we were able to limit the damage to our F/A to just 3 lost points. If Taps' ankle is okay and James and Kris recover well from their headclashes, we should bounce back strongly. Woe betide next week's opponents!
I was particularly incensed at the number of 6-agains the Warriors got, when we seemed to get none. AYK it's hard to tell in real time but it seemed like about six nil. I reckon Rick was just as peed off with that as the forward pass. Anyone got a count on them?
And mostly, I love Raiderskater's description of the referee....
- Seiffert82
- Mal Meninga
- Posts: 28135
- Joined: March 17, 2007, 12:24 pm
- Favourite Player: Bay56
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
NRL.com are now keeping track of ruck infringement stats. Apparently we conceded 5 and the Warriors 2. At least one of the Warriors two infringements was on the first tackle. I can't remember the other one. We seemed to concede all of ours late in the tackle count.Lui_Bon wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 10:40 pmI will watch the replay tomorrow. At the game today, I descended into a fog of "oh this is just schnurr schnurr." I did think our centres were doing little, though my attention was drawn to Croker getting his hand fixed.raiderskater wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 9:36 pm I disagree with the idea that no-one at the game knew anything was wrong with Scott. I was at the game and it was very, very obvious that something was very wrong with Scott. His body language was wrong, the way he was carrying his upper body was wrong. I actually texted my dad just after half time and asked if they'd said on the broadcast what Scott's injury was.
They also showed Croker having his fingers relocated on the big screen, which was probably also audible to folks at home because when they first showed Croker with his arm out at an odd angle with the trainer the ground announcer was trying to rev the crowd and the big cheer turned into this odd horrified choked noise from the crowd because I was sure - and I am equally sure I wasn't alone - that he'd done his shoulder again. The relocation of his fingers got an audible groan from the crowd.
So to me, it was obvious both centres were, to a degree, injured, though Croker seemed fine after the relocation (just tired late in the game, like everyone else).
I think it was around 30-25 minutes to go that I looked up and down our line and saw our forwards completely exhausted and realised we didn't have enough points. And we still came within a whisker of winning. I don't care if some amoeba brains in here are sick of hearing it:
I'M FRICKIN PROUD OF OUR BOYS.
They never gave up. They kept trying. They didn't roll. They fought on. They fought on against a much fresher, much less tired Warriors and an absolute cheating wankstain of a referee. And they nearly did it.
Yeah, I'm gutted tonight - probably more gutted than I should be after a round 3 game where we nearly pulled off nothing short of heroics. But I am still proud of them.
And at the end of the day, after 3 rounds we're still 2-1, and we were able to limit the damage to our F/A to just 3 lost points. If Taps' ankle is okay and James and Kris recover well from their headclashes, we should bounce back strongly. Woe betide next week's opponents!
I was particularly incensed at the number of 6-agains the Warriors got, when we seemed to get none. AYK it's hard to tell in real time but it seemed like about six nil. I reckon Rick was just as peed off with that as the forward pass. Anyone got a count on them?
And mostly, I love Raiderskater's description of the referee....
On the other hand we were only penalised once and they were penalised 5 times.
They seemed to be offside much, much more than we were, but maybe that's the green goggles talking.
It's the relentless stream of forward passes that killed us. Some of their 20 offloads were also allowed to happen quite late in the tackle, but that's obviously just my opinion.
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Yeah so the 6 agains are a bit spongey - thanks anyway, when I watch the tape tomorrow I'll try to keep count. And if I can also note when they came up in the tackle count.Seiffert82 wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 10:49 pmNRL.com are now keeping track of ruck infringement stats. Apparently we conceded 5 and the Warriors 2. At least one of the Warriors two infringements was on the first tackle. I can't remember the other one. We seemed to concede all of ours late in the tackle count.Lui_Bon wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 10:40 pmI will watch the replay tomorrow. At the game today, I descended into a fog of "oh this is just schnurr schnurr." I did think our centres were doing little, though my attention was drawn to Croker getting his hand fixed.raiderskater wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 9:36 pm I disagree with the idea that no-one at the game knew anything was wrong with Scott. I was at the game and it was very, very obvious that something was very wrong with Scott. His body language was wrong, the way he was carrying his upper body was wrong. I actually texted my dad just after half time and asked if they'd said on the broadcast what Scott's injury was.
They also showed Croker having his fingers relocated on the big screen, which was probably also audible to folks at home because when they first showed Croker with his arm out at an odd angle with the trainer the ground announcer was trying to rev the crowd and the big cheer turned into this odd horrified choked noise from the crowd because I was sure - and I am equally sure I wasn't alone - that he'd done his shoulder again. The relocation of his fingers got an audible groan from the crowd.
So to me, it was obvious both centres were, to a degree, injured, though Croker seemed fine after the relocation (just tired late in the game, like everyone else).
I think it was around 30-25 minutes to go that I looked up and down our line and saw our forwards completely exhausted and realised we didn't have enough points. And we still came within a whisker of winning. I don't care if some amoeba brains in here are sick of hearing it:
I'M FRICKIN PROUD OF OUR BOYS.
They never gave up. They kept trying. They didn't roll. They fought on. They fought on against a much fresher, much less tired Warriors and an absolute cheating wankstain of a referee. And they nearly did it.
Yeah, I'm gutted tonight - probably more gutted than I should be after a round 3 game where we nearly pulled off nothing short of heroics. But I am still proud of them.
And at the end of the day, after 3 rounds we're still 2-1, and we were able to limit the damage to our F/A to just 3 lost points. If Taps' ankle is okay and James and Kris recover well from their headclashes, we should bounce back strongly. Woe betide next week's opponents!
I was particularly incensed at the number of 6-agains the Warriors got, when we seemed to get none. AYK it's hard to tell in real time but it seemed like about six nil. I reckon Rick was just as peed off with that as the forward pass. Anyone got a count on them?
And mostly, I love Raiderskater's description of the referee....
On the other hand we were only penalised once and they were penalised 5 times.
They seemed to be offside much, much more than we were, but maybe that's the green goggles talking.
It's the relentless stream of forward passes that killed us. Some of their 20 offloads were also allowed to happen quite late in the tackle, but that's obviously just my opinion.
As for offside, I have always (well for a few years anyway) been happy to give the ref a pass because usually they drop back 12 or 13 meters, and so while it may look to everyone at the game or viewing the telly that the defence is offside, they usually aren't. Square markers are an entirely different thing of course, and that appears to be utterly subjective for the ref. Similarly with forward passes, it's clearly very hard for a ref backpedalling near the ruck to spot them. Which lead me to...
Why are touch judges getting a salary? I wouldn't feed the scum.
- zim
- Laurie Daley
- Posts: 10698
- Joined: July 8, 2015, 3:38 pm
- Favourite Player: NRL: Joseph Tapine
NRLW: Grace Kemp - Location: Sydney
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Sensational effort by the lads to stay in it. You really need something to go your way when you're down by 4 men and we got **** in that department too. Lucky we've got a lot of depth for next week.
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Cracking contest, I don't see any reason to worry too much, though. it probably came down to that 'forward' pass. Perenara looked well=positioned, but it still looked forward for all money. And when it comes to luck lets not forget the very very marginal call against RTS for a tackle in the air. Only an inch or so off the ground. Those sort are let go nine times out of ten. Papa and Sutton were immense.
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
If you watched that game, and you have knowledge and understand the duress our 17 where in, and can clearly see the difference between a W and L was an obvious and egregious refereeing error, and your take away point from that is “we should do better managing the game” then I don’t know what you want from people with that?BadnMean wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 8:39 pmI didn't see the press conference yet or have the benefit of commentary. I go to home games and no one around me had the slightest about centres being injured- we saw James and Kris collide.julian87 wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 5:24 pmThat deserves a Jesus Christ too.BadnMean wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 5:03 pmNot a sensational performance at all when you can't control a 21 pt lead, under known circumstances.
Honestly mate, that's a failure to control a game. It's literally in the teams/coaches hands at that point. Hodgo needed to be more at dummy half- Starling could have been the lock- dumb play which had each playing their weaker suit and not their strength. Wighton went missing (impression at the ground).
And some poor psoitional selections being carried cost us (Rapana). Didn't see Scott or Croker delivering much from the back 5 either.
I count that as 2 points we threw away not 2 points lost.
The middle third forwards that were left were Josh Papalii, Ryan Sutton and Sia Soliola. The team had Havili at second row. Both centres injured.
That’s on top of some embarrassing refereeing.
Nickman unfortunately needs to add mate to his list after that post.
Watch the press conference for some reality badnmean
I honestly do think with a 21 point lead, we could have done better to manage that game. IMO more Hodgo at #9 and Starling the better suited to grunt hooker work. Wighton taking a lead like he did first half.
The refereeing is aways a weak excuse. Should never be mentioned, it's embarrassing. Every team thinks they are hard done by- even Roosters fans, trust me.
Not to be rude, but if you get all that and that is still where you land about this footy game, there is nothing I or anyone can do to help you understand why the game wasn’t “managed” well by the Raiders
You’re just going to have to figure that one out on your own if those reasons are not sufficient for you
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Lads I think it's pretty simple. Was that second half tough to watch. Yes it was excruciating. Did the boys play well. Yes, it was the best performance this year. I had my old man criticise parts but like many of you I was having no of it. But frankly deep down I wanted to blame my suffering on someone or something too.
If there was one decision I found perplexing, it was that Kris passed all the tests to return but the dr took one final look at it and decided he shouldn't return. Presumably they have tests to ensure a consistent standard is applied. If he passed all those tests then surely he is allowed to return?
If there was one decision I found perplexing, it was that Kris passed all the tests to return but the dr took one final look at it and decided he shouldn't return. Presumably they have tests to ensure a consistent standard is applied. If he passed all those tests then surely he is allowed to return?
- Seiffert82
- Mal Meninga
- Posts: 28135
- Joined: March 17, 2007, 12:24 pm
- Favourite Player: Bay56
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Yes, a very questionable decision considering we had a centre out there playing 70 minutes with a broken rib.FROG wrote: ↑March 28, 2021, 7:32 am Lads I think it's pretty simple. Was that second half tough to watch. Yes it was excruciating. Did the boys play well. Yes, it was the best performance this year. I had my old man criticise parts but like many of you I was having no of it. But frankly deep down I wanted to blame my suffering on someone or something too.
If there was one decision I found perplexing, it was that Kris passed all the tests to return but the dr took one final look at it and decided he shouldn't return. Presumably they have tests to ensure a consistent standard is applied. If he passed all those tests then surely he is allowed to return?
Who's welfare is more important?
- Seiffert82
- Mal Meninga
- Posts: 28135
- Joined: March 17, 2007, 12:24 pm
- Favourite Player: Bay56
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
Yep, agree with the general idea that the refs generally stand back 11-12m. I was looking at that, he really wasn't for either team.Lui_Bon wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 11:47 pmYeah so the 6 agains are a bit spongey - thanks anyway, when I watch the tape tomorrow I'll try to keep count. And if I can also note when they came up in the tackle count.Seiffert82 wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 10:49 pmNRL.com are now keeping track of ruck infringement stats. Apparently we conceded 5 and the Warriors 2. At least one of the Warriors two infringements was on the first tackle. I can't remember the other one. We seemed to concede all of ours late in the tackle count.Lui_Bon wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 10:40 pmI will watch the replay tomorrow. At the game today, I descended into a fog of "oh this is just schnurr schnurr." I did think our centres were doing little, though my attention was drawn to Croker getting his hand fixed.raiderskater wrote: ↑March 27, 2021, 9:36 pm I disagree with the idea that no-one at the game knew anything was wrong with Scott. I was at the game and it was very, very obvious that something was very wrong with Scott. His body language was wrong, the way he was carrying his upper body was wrong. I actually texted my dad just after half time and asked if they'd said on the broadcast what Scott's injury was.
They also showed Croker having his fingers relocated on the big screen, which was probably also audible to folks at home because when they first showed Croker with his arm out at an odd angle with the trainer the ground announcer was trying to rev the crowd and the big cheer turned into this odd horrified choked noise from the crowd because I was sure - and I am equally sure I wasn't alone - that he'd done his shoulder again. The relocation of his fingers got an audible groan from the crowd.
So to me, it was obvious both centres were, to a degree, injured, though Croker seemed fine after the relocation (just tired late in the game, like everyone else).
I think it was around 30-25 minutes to go that I looked up and down our line and saw our forwards completely exhausted and realised we didn't have enough points. And we still came within a whisker of winning. I don't care if some amoeba brains in here are sick of hearing it:
I'M FRICKIN PROUD OF OUR BOYS.
They never gave up. They kept trying. They didn't roll. They fought on. They fought on against a much fresher, much less tired Warriors and an absolute cheating wankstain of a referee. And they nearly did it.
Yeah, I'm gutted tonight - probably more gutted than I should be after a round 3 game where we nearly pulled off nothing short of heroics. But I am still proud of them.
And at the end of the day, after 3 rounds we're still 2-1, and we were able to limit the damage to our F/A to just 3 lost points. If Taps' ankle is okay and James and Kris recover well from their headclashes, we should bounce back strongly. Woe betide next week's opponents!
I was particularly incensed at the number of 6-agains the Warriors got, when we seemed to get none. AYK it's hard to tell in real time but it seemed like about six nil. I reckon Rick was just as peed off with that as the forward pass. Anyone got a count on them?
And mostly, I love Raiderskater's description of the referee....
On the other hand we were only penalised once and they were penalised 5 times.
They seemed to be offside much, much more than we were, but maybe that's the green goggles talking.
It's the relentless stream of forward passes that killed us. Some of their 20 offloads were also allowed to happen quite late in the tackle, but that's obviously just my opinion.
As for offside, I have always (well for a few years anyway) been happy to give the ref a pass because usually they drop back 12 or 13 meters, and so while it may look to everyone at the game or viewing the telly that the defence is offside, they usually aren't. Square markers are an entirely different thing of course, and that appears to be utterly subjective for the ref. Similarly with forward passes, it's clearly very hard for a ref backpedalling near the ruck to spot them. Which lead me to...
Why are touch judges getting a salary? I wouldn't feed the scum.
Not sure what the touch judges were doing.
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
I'm pretty much a wins are what matters guy but that right edge had no chance. Havili was gassed and couldn't slide and Scott could barely make his first contact in defence. Just one of those things would be a disaster.
So it's not that we should be "proud" or whatever but it's just one of those games where ya gotta just move on from
So it's not that we should be "proud" or whatever but it's just one of those games where ya gotta just move on from
Re: 2021 Rd 3 V Warriors: Game Day
now ive worked out how to put my sim card into another phone after I smashed the **** into a wall, the halves went missing at the pointy end, yeah yeah a few brave efforts and all that ****.
This place is woke.