There's really not a lot of people on the side of the show writers on this one that I've seen online, it's almost universal condemnation.
And here the largest supporter they have is GE, but again... he has a serious history of unconscious bias.
Moderator: GH Moderators
There's really not a lot of people on the side of the show writers on this one that I've seen online, it's almost universal condemnation.
That also gives me a lot of confidence that major parts of that ending are D&D's, not George's.Fuifui Bradbrad wrote: ↑May 24, 2019, 11:56 am I just read that in the original script, Jorah was going to last until the end, and join Jon at the wall. The final scene was going to be Jon, Jorah and Tormund riding off into the sunset. They changed the ending because they weren’t able to justify why Jorah would ride with Jon after killing his beloved, so they changed it.
That gave me a bit of confidence, that they had a crack at closing some of the plot holes. Imagine the reaction if that happened!
Sent from my iPhone using The Greenhouse mobile app powered by Tapatalk
That’s right, not to be confused with Negans “I hope you have your ******* pants on!”PigRickman wrote:I believe correct terminology would be “which one of you cowards **** in my pants?”Fuifui Bradbrad wrote: ↑May 24, 2019, 10:01 am and the only word I could understand was “Sydney”, I would be asking who **** in my pants
NerdThe Rickman wrote: ↑May 24, 2019, 11:56 amThere's really not a lot of people on the side of the show writers on this one that I've seen online, it's almost universal condemnation.
And here the largest supporter they have is GE, but again... he has a serious history of unconscious bias.
Well I'd rather be a nerd than a... than a... jerk!Northern Raider wrote: ↑May 24, 2019, 12:02 pmNerdThe Rickman wrote: ↑May 24, 2019, 11:56 amThere's really not a lot of people on the side of the show writers on this one that I've seen online, it's almost universal condemnation.
And here the largest supporter they have is GE, but again... he has a serious history of unconscious bias.
It's cool guy hour here on the GH.
Haha, reminded me of thisPigRickman wrote:It's cool guy hour here on the GH.
yeah well my Giant could beat your Direwolf in a fightNorthern Raider wrote: ↑May 24, 2019, 12:02 pmNerdThe Rickman wrote: ↑May 24, 2019, 11:56 amThere's really not a lot of people on the side of the show writers on this one that I've seen online, it's almost universal condemnation.
And here the largest supporter they have is GE, but again... he has a serious history of unconscious bias.
I'm as pissed as anyone on the plot holes in the last episode, but I don't think that you had understand what she was saying to know what she was getting at. Her intentions were pretty clear.PigRickman wrote:What evidence did the show give the idea that Jon AND Arya had sound understanding of the language?
That’s the point, if you want to make that scene work, put some dialogue somewhere in the lead up eps to show he’s picked up some Dothraki.
That’s what the show did so incredibly well for 6 seasons and the type of super bad short cuts they’ve made since losing the source material
Could notSid wrote: ↑May 24, 2019, 12:36 pmyeah well my Giant could beat your Direwolf in a fightNorthern Raider wrote: ↑May 24, 2019, 12:02 pmNerdThe Rickman wrote: ↑May 24, 2019, 11:56 amThere's really not a lot of people on the side of the show writers on this one that I've seen online, it's almost universal condemnation.
And here the largest supporter they have is GE, but again... he has a serious history of unconscious bias.
Big upgrade up the one we got though, so credit where it's due there!gangrenous wrote: ↑May 24, 2019, 6:51 pm Drogon should have blasted Jon in anger and Jon be all like “I’m a Targ ****, you owe me a new cloak”. Then Drogon eats him.
Yeah... that’s how it should have gone
Some Snow EDIT is all i wanted if im being honest.gangrenous wrote: ↑May 24, 2019, 8:32 pm Yeah, no plot holes and some Jon Snow nudity. My ending would have appeased the masses!
Ha. Now it looks worsePigRickman wrote:Some Snow EDIT is all i wanted if im being honest.gangrenous wrote: ↑May 24, 2019, 8:32 pm Yeah, no plot holes and some Jon Snow nudity. My ending would have appeased the masses!
Yeah I’ll give you that one. I didn’t buy the throwaway line that half of them stayed in Dragonstone.PigRickman wrote:So I was thinking... this might be the worst part of GoT
They send out the Dothraki in the long night, they get snuffed out a flame/man
Like the story was no one survived that charge
And then randomly half of them did survive, they multiplied only to have them go against their entire life philosophy and they weren’t even needed for the KL sacking!
Wouldnt it have just been better to commit to their wipe out? They brought them back, in ridiculous fashion only for them to not play any real role, the show could go exactly the same as it did without the Dothraki after the long night, just to have the resettled in Westeros?!?
I can’t stop thinking about how wildly **** dumb that is!
They don’t no matter what you doFuifui Bradbrad wrote:Meanwhile, I just finished the Telltale GoT game... my choices didn’t end too well hahaha
Yeah, but in the end I made some choices I was like “Man, should have went the other way.”The Rickman wrote:They don’t no matter what you doFuifui Bradbrad wrote:Meanwhile, I just finished the Telltale GoT game... my choices didn’t end too well hahaha
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
100% Mad Dany, Jon back to establish the Night's Watch, Queen Sansa, Bran on the Throne... that's all a perfectly fine ending, like you some of that is not how i saw it going but that all on the face of it makes sense... if you took the time to do it right. They just didnt because the DD's rushed it.Dr Zaius wrote: ↑May 25, 2019, 12:31 pm I'd have been fine with the ending if they had taken their time and reached those conclusions. I mean, they are not necessarily the endings that I would have chosen for those characters, but I don't get to decide. It was all to rushed. I read somewhere (maybe here) that GRRM originally wanted 13 seasons to tell his story. The DDs wanted 7. They compromised with 8, the last two of which where abridged. Says it all really. It's a shame because it put a dampener on what was otherwise a brilliant series.
What’s the next show you’re into now? I’ve just caught up on Chernobyl. It’s great, but you can’t really discuss and theories about it the way you can with GoT.PigRickman wrote:Still im going to miss this show, im going to miss thinking about it and theorising about it. It's been a great ride.
In terms of a reaction though, you won't get many bigger.Fuifui Bradbrad wrote: ↑May 26, 2019, 10:15 pmWhat’s the next show you’re into now? I’ve just caught up on Chernobyl. It’s great, but you can’t really discuss and theories about it the way you can with GoT.PigRickman wrote:Still im going to miss this show, im going to miss thinking about it and theorising about it. It's been a great ride.
I’m doubting we’ll be covering off plot holes of a nuclear meltdown
You’re fission for a laugh aren’t you?BadnMean wrote:In terms of a reaction though, you won't get many bigger.Fuifui Bradbrad wrote: ↑May 26, 2019, 10:15 pmWhat’s the next show you’re into now? I’ve just caught up on Chernobyl. It’s great, but you can’t really discuss and theories about it the way you can with GoT.PigRickman wrote:Still im going to miss this show, im going to miss thinking about it and theorising about it. It's been a great ride.
I’m doubting we’ll be covering off plot holes of a nuclear meltdown
Yeah we just blasted through the the first three eps of Chernobyl tooFuifui Bradbrad wrote: ↑May 26, 2019, 10:15 pmWhat’s the next show you’re into now? I’ve just caught up on Chernobyl. It’s great, but you can’t really discuss and theories about it the way you can with GoT.PigRickman wrote:Still im going to miss this show, im going to miss thinking about it and theorising about it. It's been a great ride.
I’m doubting we’ll be covering off plot holes of a nuclear meltdown
Yeah I’m loving it too. I just watch scenes where they’re all “We need 3 people to go into that water and turn these taps off, otherwise 3/4 of Europe are going to die...”PigRickman wrote:Yeah we just blasted through the the first three eps of Chernobyl tooFuifui Bradbrad wrote: ↑May 26, 2019, 10:15 pmWhat’s the next show you’re into now? I’ve just caught up on Chernobyl. It’s great, but you can’t really discuss and theories about it the way you can with GoT.PigRickman wrote:Still im going to miss this show, im going to miss thinking about it and theorising about it. It's been a great ride.
I’m doubting we’ll be covering off plot holes of a nuclear meltdown
Really **** great show
But yeah not quite the wide ranging story with character development haha