If we lose Joey, yes.
All else remains to be seen. I’m expecting improvements from the majority of the squad, with natural progression and maturity.
Moderator: GH Moderators
If we lose Joey, yes.
Also get to sign the best players from the weakest clubs with a net zero effect on your salary cap.kona_dream wrote:Career ending injuries don't really matter any more. Just retire and get a salary cap exemption and pay the player to be an ambassador.
best players full stop, latrell mitchell was hardly from a weak club.
I think we've got the squad to challenge for a premiership this year. I was a bit worried a few months back about our chances this year if we lost Leilua but Curtis Scott is a great replacement. Simonsson for Rapana isn't a bad trade off either. I wouldn't rank either above the player they're replacing but they're both younger players on the rise whereas the two they're replacing are older players on the wane.
It all comes down to cost and it's impossible to say without knowing the exact position of the club as far as the salary cap goes
It completely depends on whether Jordy is forever a shadow of his former self or whether he just needed a full injury free pre season under the belt to get back to his best. We'll probably never know now as he's not going to have a pre season with us even if he does come back after his rugby stint.nemesis wrote:After the NRL blocked rapana coming back on a cheap deal i had the feeling they would look to get rid of BJ to free up cap space for rapana to return.
If this happens will people like that more or would they prefer to keep BJ?
If he goes to the Tigers I sure hope that's the case!Coastalraider wrote: ↑January 20, 2020, 6:50 pm I’m just not sure that madge and his robotic training/systems are going to be good for Joey.
If G.Williams aint it, Beej isnt going to save us from the turn in fortunes that's coming.
No they don't, but they have to pay him a salary that's enough to make him want to move rather than accept a possible downgrade in Canberra. Why would he move for a wage that's less than what he's on here, or less than what he could get for maybe a slight downgrade here? Unless he's been told that he's not wanted here at all, and that isn't the case as far as I know.
His brother is at the tigers and all his family are in Sydney, possibly more reasons to go then stay in canberra.Lui_Bon wrote: ↑January 20, 2020, 9:25 pmNo they don't, but they have to pay him a salary that's enough to make him want to move rather than accept a possible downgrade in Canberra. Why would he move for a wage that's less than what he's on here, or less than what he could get for maybe a slight downgrade here? Unless he's been told that he's not wanted here at all, and that isn't the case as far as I know.
Wests Tigers meet Joey Leilua, prepare to offer Doueihi a dealOld School Green wrote: ↑January 20, 2020, 8:29 pm I know they said he was training with the rehab group last week but it’s possible he is just staying away until this is sorted.
No sightings in gear on the gram (his or other players) and just starting to smell like it’s a done deal being finalised and announced.
I hope not. I think we are a better team with him and that’s bottom line for me.
Well, if his wife wants to stay he's more likely too. Though maybe now that the Rapanas are gone there's less incentive.cat wrote: ↑January 20, 2020, 9:31 pmHis brother is at the tigers and all his family are in Sydney, possibly more reasons to go then stay in canberra.Lui_Bon wrote: ↑January 20, 2020, 9:25 pmNo they don't, but they have to pay him a salary that's enough to make him want to move rather than accept a possible downgrade in Canberra. Why would he move for a wage that's less than what he's on here, or less than what he could get for maybe a slight downgrade here? Unless he's been told that he's not wanted here at all, and that isn't the case as far as I know.
There are some boys I can see staying in Canberra once they retire, bj is not one of them
If Williams ends up however as a "solid" but not spectacular halfback in our squad, then we will still need that x factor / strike power (kind of like Sezer this year). I guess this is all guesswork and time will tell.Botman wrote: ↑January 20, 2020, 8:07 pmIf G.Williams aint it, Beej isnt going to save us from the turn in fortunes that's coming.
Im very keen on keeping Beej and to me he's my #4 until he's not here and Scott/Simo situation can figure itself out, but i dont agree we've moved further away... at least not on paper
There is absolutely no reason to believe an international half wont be an upgrade @ #7. And as long as he is, we're a better team even without Joey. Scott is no bum, he's a very talented footballer, different sort of player but very talented.
Overall, whilst i want to keep Beej... this season and our chances rest on George Williams. If he's legit quality NRL half, we're going to be really hard to beat, with or without Beej... if he sucks, we're going to be in for a decline, with or without Beej.
Scott was on 1.5 million over 3 years at the Storm. I'm guessing it was an incremental deal so he'd be on 500-550 this year.kiwi raider wrote: ↑January 21, 2020, 6:18 am BJ on 700k for 2020, we probably got Curtis Scott for around half of that
The fact G-Williams was substantially below Jackson Hastings in the English half rankings is my concern. Time will tell as you say.Azza wrote: ↑January 21, 2020, 6:22 amIf Williams ends up however as a "solid" but not spectacular halfback in our squad, then we will still need that x factor / strike power (kind of like Sezer this year). I guess this is all guesswork and time will tell.Botman wrote: ↑January 20, 2020, 8:07 pmIf G.Williams aint it, Beej isnt going to save us from the turn in fortunes that's coming.
Im very keen on keeping Beej and to me he's my #4 until he's not here and Scott/Simo situation can figure itself out, but i dont agree we've moved further away... at least not on paper
There is absolutely no reason to believe an international half wont be an upgrade @ #7. And as long as he is, we're a better team even without Joey. Scott is no bum, he's a very talented footballer, different sort of player but very talented.
Overall, whilst i want to keep Beej... this season and our chances rest on George Williams. If he's legit quality NRL half, we're going to be really hard to beat, with or without Beej... if he sucks, we're going to be in for a decline, with or without Beej.
Yeah fair point... it's weird though, because there is a WIDE area of grey where he could land and be as you said, just a solid but unspectacular Sezer type... but i dont see it. I think he's going to be really good, or really badAzza wrote: ↑January 21, 2020, 6:22 amIf Williams ends up however as a "solid" but not spectacular halfback in our squad, then we will still need that x factor / strike power (kind of like Sezer this year). I guess this is all guesswork and time will tell.Botman wrote: ↑January 20, 2020, 8:07 pmIf G.Williams aint it, Beej isnt going to save us from the turn in fortunes that's coming.
Im very keen on keeping Beej and to me he's my #4 until he's not here and Scott/Simo situation can figure itself out, but i dont agree we've moved further away... at least not on paper
There is absolutely no reason to believe an international half wont be an upgrade @ #7. And as long as he is, we're a better team even without Joey. Scott is no bum, he's a very talented footballer, different sort of player but very talented.
Overall, whilst i want to keep Beej... this season and our chances rest on George Williams. If he's legit quality NRL half, we're going to be really hard to beat, with or without Beej... if he sucks, we're going to be in for a decline, with or without Beej.
Jackson who?Roger Kenworthy wrote: ↑January 21, 2020, 6:48 amThe fact G-Williams was substantially below Jackson Hastings in the English half rankings is my concern. Time will tell as you say.Azza wrote: ↑January 21, 2020, 6:22 amIf Williams ends up however as a "solid" but not spectacular halfback in our squad, then we will still need that x factor / strike power (kind of like Sezer this year). I guess this is all guesswork and time will tell.Botman wrote: ↑January 20, 2020, 8:07 pmIf G.Williams aint it, Beej isnt going to save us from the turn in fortunes that's coming.
Im very keen on keeping Beej and to me he's my #4 until he's not here and Scott/Simo situation can figure itself out, but i dont agree we've moved further away... at least not on paper
There is absolutely no reason to believe an international half wont be an upgrade @ #7. And as long as he is, we're a better team even without Joey. Scott is no bum, he's a very talented footballer, different sort of player but very talented.
Overall, whilst i want to keep Beej... this season and our chances rest on George Williams. If he's legit quality NRL half, we're going to be really hard to beat, with or without Beej... if he sucks, we're going to be in for a decline, with or without Beej.