Rankings

Nick · Post by **Nick** » January 8, 2005, 9:03 pm

greeneyed wrote:Seems to be consensus the current ones aren't much good.

seems that way

i like the idea of raiders players but i recon it would be sweet to work up from like Albert Fulavai to say a less **** player but **** crap - Greg Wolfgram and then to an average past player like Pongia etc if ya get what im saying

With Mal being #1 or something

Sasha · Post by **Sasha** » January 8, 2005, 9:06 pm

Wolfgram
Bulgarelli
Thompson
Pongia
McLinden
Schifcofske
Stuart
Daley
Wiki
Meninga

Thoughts?

Although I think people might prefer having someone like Chalk under their name then Bulgarelli

paulquinn49 · Post by **paulquinn49** » January 9, 2005, 11:06 am

We should only have 6 levels.

Elliot Fan
Season 2003 Groupie
Gary Belcher
Laurie Daley
Mal Meninga
Alan Tongue

Post by **greeneyed** » January 9, 2005, 11:11 am

paulquinn49 wrote:We should only have 6 levels.

Elliot Fan
Season 2003 Groupie
Gary Belcher
Laurie Daley
Mal Meninga
Alan Tongue

Tongue....

Canberra Milk · Post by **Canberra Milk** » January 9, 2005, 12:28 pm

Raiders 2005 wrote:I like going with actual league status than players...

Debut
SG Ball
Premier League
First Grade Bench
First Grade
State Of Origin Rep
Club International

and for the Mods - Coach

nah, it's too LU-like...

Canberra Milk · Post by **Canberra Milk** » January 9, 2005, 12:30 pm

i like the current options, they're funny. but if we wanna change it, then i reckon **** players -> great players would be the best idea.

Schifty - how the hell is Todd Carney above Phil Graham?!

Sasha · Post by **Sasha** » January 9, 2005, 1:51 pm

Kris_man wrote:i like the current options, they're funny. but if we wanna change it, then i reckon **** players -> great players would be the best idea.

Schifty - how the hell is Todd Carney above Phil Graham?!

Because as much as I am a fan of Phil Graham, Todd Carney has been labled "our next big thing". Phil has been in and out of first grade, but hopefully now has established himself.

I just put the "next big thins" as a higher rank then required more posts to deserve

tonio · Post by **tonio** » January 9, 2005, 2:45 pm

How about

Todd Carney
Phil Graham
Craig Frawley
Michael Hodgson
Ryan O'Hara
Jason Croker
Clinton Schifcofske
Simon Woolford

Something Like that?

Post by **greeneyed** » January 9, 2005, 2:47 pm

No, I prefer the legendary players lists myself. Or at least a combination. Mal and Laurie, Ricky and Brad should be at the top of the tree. I think there would be a lot more consensus that this list is, in order, our greatest players..... then Walters, Badge.... probably.

paulquinn49 · Post by **paulquinn49** » January 9, 2005, 4:17 pm

I included some greats in mine.

69 my list is the way to go. Maybe Schifty can create one of his famous polls.

Canberra Milk · Post by **Canberra Milk** » January 9, 2005, 8:19 pm

Schifty wrote:
Kris_man wrote:i like the current options, they're funny. but if we wanna change it, then i reckon **** players -> great players would be the best idea.

Schifty - how the hell is Todd Carney above Phil Graham?!
Because as much as I am a fan of Phil Graham, Todd Carney has been labled "our next big thing". Phil has been in and out of first grade, but hopefully now has established himself.

I just put the "next big thing" as a higher rank then required more posts to deserve

there's no comparison. Phil Graham was our top tryscorer in 2002, and has a fantastic tryscoring stirke rate - one of the best in the league as a matter of fact. both got rookie of the year in their debut seasons, but Phil Graham actually deserved his (Josh Miller was robbed, seriously)

DJ Raida · Post by **DJ Raida** » January 9, 2005, 8:37 pm

being of such a low rank sucks

Raider Azz · Post by **Raider Azz** » January 11, 2005, 9:16 am

Kris_man wrote:
Schifty wrote:
Kris_man wrote:i like the current options, they're funny. but if we wanna change it, then i reckon **** players -> great players would be the best idea.

Schifty - how the hell is Todd Carney above Phil Graham?!
Because as much as I am a fan of Phil Graham, Todd Carney has been labled "our next big thing". Phil has been in and out of first grade, but hopefully now has established himself.

I just put the "next big thing" as a higher rank then required more posts to deserve
there's no comparison. Phil Graham was our top tryscorer in 2002, and has a fantastic tryscoring stirke rate - one of the best in the league as a matter of fact. both got rookie of the year in their debut seasons, but Phil Graham actually deserved his (Josh Miller was robbed, seriously)

I agree, Phil should be above Carney. Carney isn't even an established first grader yet.